For many years I lived in Saint Minneapolis, an urban area really not much different in population than the city I live in now. But ever since some recent encounters with the beach crows I have been thinking a lot about the differences. Not the obvious ones about food and culture, or the age of the buildings, or even the respective density of these cities layouts.
No, I have been thinking about the animals, what they're like and how I relate to them.
Saint Minneapolis had a streak of wildness running through it. Part of that was built into the ferocity of its weather, but some of it was in the preserved river running through its heart too. It was, is, still a lively sanctuary for the wilderness, not just a protected flyway, and a National Park, but an ever accessible, unbroken safe zone for everything wild and feral and seeking the ungoverned. Too prone to flooding, too conveniently below the city to ever really be developed much, it connected wild and tamed, north and south, as well as ancient and present.
And so the animals there in Saint Minneapolis had that edge to them. From the eagles to coyotes, deer to turkeys, they appeared into our world from out of their own. Even the crows and the squirrels, even the pets of people, had that touch of independence, that whiff of the uncontained.
I missed that when I came here. It felt like there were fewer animals here, despite all the hills and pretty country, and the animals I did see seemed less thrilling, from the seagulls and pigeons to the rats and dogs.
But I started to settle in. To be happy in Europe I had to let go a little of wildness being the marker of animals. That pigeon investigating my boot is as much an encounter with other beings as were the squirrels of my old neighborhoods. The comedy of a seagull at my window, the calm friendliness of some dog in a cafe, the crows, comfortably unperturbed by me on the beach, all of this suggested something delightfully different here.
I miss some of that encounter with wildness here in such a mad New York City like city, crammed with people and business and event at every block and store and cafe. I miss that blast of wild smoke, the shock of other untouched air, the watchfulness and attention, the mystery behind the facade of reality. But on the other hand, here is a strange kind of personableness. I go to the fish market with the seagulls. I share the grand central squares and olde cafes with the pigeons. And yes, down on the beach, the crows and I do whatever we do, with no great wariness, no edge. We share it.
And so there is my difference for you. Everything, from the starlings to the cats, feels less wild here. People have been building and living in cities here for thousands of years now. Agreements have been reached. But if everything is less wild here, then nothing is quite as domesticated either. It doesn't feel so much like anything is compromised, no war forsaken or opportunity paid for, but something else, an adaptation that has already taken place.
It's... cosier. For both of us.
We just live here.
























